Our Best Holiday Pie Recipes

When it comes to the holiday season, we just can’t get enough pie. That’s why we collected our best holiday pie recipes for you to make the season merry and bright.

Are you a stickler for the classics or do you like to tweak tradition? Either way, our best pie recipes have something for you. Add nuts to your crust or go vegan for the crowd-favorite pumpkin pie. Can’t decide on just one? Go for the best of both worlds with a sweet potato apple pie.

Many of our holiday pie recipes can be made ahead of time, keeping the stress at bay during the hectic season. If you prefer to make your pies day-of, you can still save time by making a few batches of our Simple Piecrust and freezing it until ready to use.

Before you bake, be sure to check out our top 10 baking tips for holiday pie success. You can also use our helpful servings calculator to determine just how many holiday pie recipes to make for your crowd. And don’t forget the whipped cream!

Classic Pecan Pie
Recipe Rating: 3.36358
Sugared Cranberry and Lemon Curd Pie
Recipe Rating: 3.07933
Eggnog Pie
Recipe Rating: 3.12625
Vegan Pumpkin Pecan Pie
Recipe Rating: 3.05346
Sweet Potato Apple Pie
Recipe Rating: 3.05392
Vegan Mocha Pie
Recipe Rating: 3.91217