More Than 9 Coffee Add-Ins You Have to Try

Coffee purists beware: This post explores coffee add-ins beyond a splash of cream or milk such as sugar, spice and everything nice — even butter and marshmallows!

Cardamom Coffee

Cardamom Coffee opens in a new tab

Coffee purists beware: This post explores coffee add-ins beyond a splash of cream or milk such as sugar, spice and everything nice — even butter and marshmallows!

I appreciate (need, want, love) my morning coffee and keep it pretty simple at home. But when I’m buying a cup of coffee, I’m often tempted by flavors and exciting riffs on the traditional cup of Joe. So I started wondering what I can do at home to change up my predicable coffee routine. After a bit of research and some delicious experimenting, I’m happy to share my findings.

Here’s how you too can make your coffee routine special with just a splash, sprinkle, stir-in or dollop:

  • Spices. Have you tired adding spices to the coffee grounds before brewing yet? Cinnamon and nutmeg are common additions but allspice, ginger or even a sprinkle of cayenne pepper are worth experimenting with too. Strong coffee flavored with cardamom is popular in Israel and other parts of the Middle East. Learn how with this Cardamom Coffee opens in a new tab recipe.

  • Sweetened condensed milk. My perfect afternoon treat is a Vietnamese iced coffee made with strong coffee and a couple of tablespoons of sweetened condensed milk. So simple. So good.

  • Flavoring syrups. Opt for syrups with no artificial flavors, and you can DIY your favorite flavored lattes at home. (Get seasonal and make a pumpkin latte!)

  • Vanilla/almond extract. Looking for a flavor booster that’s likely already in your fridge? Try adding a few drops of pure vanilla or almond extract and voila!

  • Grass-fed butter. Recently it seems as if everyone is talking about this coffee addition inspired by traditional Tibetan yak butter tea. A recipe I’ve come across a few times suggests putting 1 cup of brewed coffee into a blender with 1 teaspoon grass-fed unsalted butter and 1 tablespoon coconut oil and mixing until frothy. Have you tried it yet?

  • Non-dairy milks. Almond milk and coconut milk are available in varieties such as vanilla and chocolate. For iced coffee, I have been making cold-brew coffee (Learn to Cook: Cold-Brewed Coffee opens in a new tab), then freezing it in an ice cube tray to prevent water dilution. When I’m ready for an iced coffee, I fill my glass with the iced coffee cubes and pour in almond milk.

  • Whipped cream. It’s cream and sugar in one!

  • Ice cream. You may have seen affogatos on menus at local coffee shop or cafes. It’s the perfect marriage — espresso and gelato. Sounds good, right? Try Coffee-Splashed Peppermint Ice Cream opens in a new tab. Some variations also include whipped cream or a shot of amaretto or other liqueur.

  • More! And that’s just the start. How about a touch of maple syrup or pomegranate molasses opens in a new tab, a sprinkle of unsweetened cocoa powder or flavored sugars such as Vanilla Bean Sugar opens in a new tab, marshmallows or liqueurs (for non-work days, of course).

Learn to Cook: Cold-Brewed Coffee

Learn to Cook: Cold-Brewed Coffee opens in a new tab

A Good Cup Starts with Good Beans

It is said that every cup of coffee tells a story. When you know that story, you’ll appreciate your daily jolt that much more. Here are three blends from Allegro® Coffee worth checking out:

  • Blue Nile Blend. This blend of beans from Ethiopia, the birthplace of Arabica coffee, is a medium roast with intense berry and spice notes. As an extra perk, your purchase supports Girls Gotta Run Foundation opens in a new tab, a non-profit organization that provides scholarships to Ethiopian girls.

  • Organic Congo SOPACDI. This bright, crisp light roast with lime, green apple and blood orange flavors helps provide economic stability to the SOPACDI Cooperative, especially to female members to help them provide for their families. It’s fair trade and Non-GMO Project verified too.

  • Café UBUNTU. With rich notes of golden raisin, maple and fig and a long sweet finish, there’s more to it than a satisfying cup of coffee. This light roast shares its name with a farm-to-table café and coffee shop in Maai Mahiu, Kenya opens in a new tab. The café is a project of Comfort the Children International opens in a new tab (CTC International), a non-profit that works alongside Kenyan communities to create sustainable change. In addition to creating jobs in the community, Café Ubuntu serves as a much-needed health and nutrition resource center for the Rift Valley and provides education to the community about sustainable farming.

How do you take your coffee? Have you tried any of the suggestions above or do you have your own recommendations? Share in the comments below. 

Explore More