Skip main navigation

Our Top Picks for American Cheese Month

October is American Cheese Month, and it’s the perfect time to celebrate the country’s best cheeses.

Cheese Display

October is the quintessential all-American month. It’s a time for tailgates, football games, apple picking, baseball playoffs and…cheese!

That’s because October is American Cheese Month, a time to celebrate the country’s best cheeses.

To get in the spirit we asked a few of our cheesemongers (many of whom are Certified Cheese Professionals™!)  for their picks Here’s what they’re eating this month:

  • Alpha Tolman aged at the Cellars at Jasper Hill — Greensboro, Vermont: A raw cow’s milk cheese that when mature, is bold and savory with butter and caramelized onion flavors.

  • Rawstruck by Coach Farms — Pine Plains, New York: A raw, goat’s milk cheese that is hand-crafted in small batches once a month. It has a complex flavor, with nuances of mushrooms and faint citrus notes.  

  • Rum Runner BellaVitano by Sartori — Plymouth, Wisconsin: A rich, creamy cow’s milk cheese whose buttery flavors, and slightly sweet aromatics come alive when soaked in a Wisconsin-produced “Heath rum.” It’s only available at Whole Foods Market stores!

  • Flora Nelle by Rogue Creamery — Central Point, Oregon: This is a bold and earthy cow’s milk blue cheese that is crumbly to cut and creamy on the palate, with a long finish.

  • Five Peppercorn Raclette by EMMI Roth USA — Monroe, Wisconsin: This cow’s milk cheese has a distinct aroma, a velvety texture and a mild nutty flavor that has pleasantly sharp tastes from distinct peppercorns. A Whole Foods Market exclusive!

  • Grand Cru Reserve Wheel by EMMI Roth USA — Monroe Wisconsin: Wheels of Grand Cru are hand-selected for six to nine months of additional curing, developing nutty undertones and hints of fruitiness in this award-winning cow’s milk cheese.

  • Humboldt Fog by Cypress Grove — Arcata, California: This renowned goat’s milk cheese has a subtle, tangy flavor with a fresh cream taste, floral notes, herbal overtones and a citrus finish along with a distinctive layer of edible ash.

  • Asiago with Rosemary by Saxon Creamery — Cleveland, Wisconsin: This cow’s milk cheese has a delicate texture and a mild flavor studded with notes of rosemary. It makes a fantastic addition to a cheese plate and is also great for melting in recipes. It’s only available at Whole Foods Market!

American Cheese Month is a great reason to head over to the cheese department and give one of these delicious cheeses a try (our cheesemongers are happy to let you have a taste before you buy). Better yet, get your friends together and celebrate the month with an American cheese tasting party. 
What is your favorite American cheese?

Explore More